HOW IT WORKS
How we find value, and how we count it
Puntlyst publishes value bets on Betfair Exchange football markets. This page sets out exactly how a pick is made, how it is settled and how the backtest was run.
1. Our fair odds
Betfair's prices in these markets are good but biased in places. Long-shot goalscorers to score twice, for example, win less often than their price says, and sending-off "Yes" has historically won only about three quarters as often as priced. We measure those biases from years of Betfair's own results, and correct for them:
- Betfair's price: the last traded price 45 minutes before kick-off, after team news (when Betfair removes non-starters from player markets). If nothing has traded, the midpoint of the best back and lay offers.
- Our factor: how Betfair's prices have done against results. Player markets (goalscorer, 2 or more, hat-trick, shown a card) are grouped by price range; corners, booking points and sending off by selection.
- Fair odds = Betfair's price × our factor. They are fixed at 45 minutes before kick-off and don't change afterwards.
2. When a pick is published
- From our fair odds we work out the limit: the worst Betfair price that still gives at least 20% value, after 2% commission. Value is the expected profit per 1 point of stake (backer's stake for a lay).
- From 45 minutes before kick-off until the market goes in play, we check Betfair's prices every minute. When the price first reaches the limit, the pick is published.
- Only markets with a profitable record in the backtest are picked, each with its own minimum value: Lay · First goalscorer (30%), Lay · Sending off · Yes (20%), Lay · To score 2 or more (20%), Lay · Anytime goalscorer (30%). The minimum values and the list of markets were set in November 2026 from the backtest's full history.
- The first 3 picks published each day (UK time) are the free picks, decided at the moment they are published, never afterwards.
3. Settlement
- A pick is stored with its fair odds, limit, Betfair's price and the time, when it is published. Our database refuses any change or deletion of a published pick.
- Results are settled at the limit price, with Betfair's result. A lay order left at the limit is matched at that price, so this is the price you can count on, even when Betfair's price at publication was better.
- Stakes: 1 point. A back risks its 1-point stake. A lay is 1 point backer's stake and risks its liability, stake × (odds − 1). 2% commission on winnings. Non-runners are void.
- Return on risked = profit ÷ the total amount risked (back stakes plus lay liabilities).
4. The backtest
The backtest runs exactly these rules over Betfair's historic data from Mar 2021 to Aug 2026, using only what was known at the time:
- Walk-forward fair odds: each month's factors are learnt only from the months before it, starting after 6 months of data.
- Walk-forward market choice: in each month, a market is picked only if its picks in the earlier months, at least 200 of them, made a profit.
- Prices: Betfair's traded prices. Fair odds from the last trade 45 minutes before kick-off; a pick when a traded price after that, before kick-off, reached the limit; settled at the limit with Betfair's result and 2% commission.
- Betfair's historic data has a few gaps (January 2024 is missing), and matches with no trade 45 minutes before kick-off are left out.
The backtest and the live record are always shown separately. The live record starts with the first pick published on this site.
What to expect
The edge is small. Over the backtest, picks returned 1.11% of the amount risked, and 17 of 61 months lost money. Most picks are lays, many at long odds, so a single winner can cost many points. Stake so that a run of losing months is comfortable. If a price has gone, don't chase it.